This Passover I added an olive branch to my seder plate. After doing a bit of research on how to acknowledge the conflicts around the world, I landed on the olive branch as a sign of peace. In doing so, I realized I might also create a space for dialogue at the Seder table where not every family member agrees on how to achieve peace. My father encouraged me, reminding me, reminding me to allow everyone to be heard, to build community by acknowledging that differing opinions are both expected and honored.
This notion was echoed in the Pardes Institute’s Mahloket Matters Fellowship I participated in this fall. A mahloket is a disagreement. The fellowship posited that Jewish teachings promote constructive disagreement, creating space for deeper meaning, relationship building, and better solutions — essentially transforming conflict into a method to build bridges and community.
What’s Jewish about constructive disagreement? You may have your own answers for this drawing from your recent Passover Seder or family squabble! Diving into rabbinical texts in the fellowship, we explored the notion that not even Moses was blessed with knowing everything. This humbles each of us to accept that truth for ourselves as well. We also learned that the Sanhedrin (Jewish supreme religious court) encouraged disagreement (not uniformity) to find better solutions.
According to Pardes’ Mahloket Matters Fellowship, the four pillars of a constructive disagreement are:
- Debate the issues without attacking people and harming relationships.
- Check your motivation. Are you trying to win or to understand and solve problems?
- Listen to the other side and be open to admitting that you might be wrong.
- Consider that you might both be right despite holding opposite positions.
In the spirit of constructive disagreement, I used the olive branch on my seder plate to open a conversation where the diverse perspectives at my table could be respected.
This spirit is what led me to the Pozez JCC, where we build community every day by listening to everyone and making space for disagreement. The six J-Family Ambassadors I support are opening conversations with young Jewish families looking to connect and build community throughout Northern Virginia. They are creating events based on their community’s expressed desires and meeting people where they are to support growing families and their Jewish identity.
The Pozez JCC has supported the J-Family Ambassador Program from its inception here in Northern Virginia and promotes an environment of learning and dialogue. Pozez leadership also encouraged my participation in Mahloket Matters, recently hosted a workshop from For the Sake of Argument (a program that also builds skills for constructive disagreement), and continues to support diverse and thoughtful programming with a welcoming communal atmosphere. We always welcome suggestions, so if you have a program you want to see, please let us know!
You can join us in the spirit of building a rich, diverse community in any of the following ways:
- Come to the Pozez JCC and see what the buzz is about! You’ll always find a friendly face and an engaging activity, ranging from special events to fitness to Mah Jongg in the lobby.
- Know a new parent looking to connect Jewishly in their community? Connect them with our J-Family Ambassador Program.
- Check out Growing Jewish Families’ latest programming that families can enjoy together.








